Place Your Order

All baked goods are lovingly made by Sarah using only premium ingredients, including pure Madagascar Bourbon vanilla extract, North Dakota flours, sugars and honey, real chocolate, pure maple syrup, and grade AA unsalted butter.

Because each order is made from scratch by Sarah in her home kitchen, advance notice is appreciated. Once your order is received, you will receive an email within 24 hours to confirm each item and provide details to submit your payment online. Sarah is the sole baker in her kitchen and may be up to her elbows in buttercream when your order is placed, and we appreciate your patience as it may take up to 24 hours to send a confirmation reply.

While Sarah will fill your order as quickly as possible, when demand is great orders will typically take 5 to 7 days to fulfill. If time is a factor in your order, please indicate that when you list your items. SarahBakes is happy to serve the local Fargo-Moorhead area and North Dakota market.

Every item is prepared with your comfort, joy and safety in mind. We are pleased to offer Contact-free pickup from Sarah’s home, if desired. All pickups for orders placed after Dec. 17 will be scheduled between 5 to 7 PM unless otherwise arranged with Sarah.

SarahBakes Menu

Sarah’s Holiday Menu is available through December 31, 2020.

Please allow at least 3 to 5 days for orders to be filled. Custom orders may take longer to fill and advance notice is appreciated!

Breakfast/PastriesChristmas/Holiday SpecialtiesCookies Candies & Savories
Ready-to-Bake Frozen Scones
Choice of Cherry Vanilla, or

Cranberry Orange

Miniature Pastries Assortment
Cherry Vanilla Scones
Cran-Orange Streusel Muffins
Sliced Holiday Quick Breads
$32/24 pieces
$48/36 pieces
$64/48 pieces

Mini Cran-Orange Streusel Muffins
$20/2 dozen

Cherry Vanilla Scones
(8 large or 16 small scones)

Fresh Cranberry Orange Scones
(8 large or 16 small scones)
Cookies & Sweets Assortment:
Italian Butter Cookies
Sugar Cookie Cutouts
Coconut Macaroons
Chocolate Icebox Cookies
Christmas Candy

(Candy choices: Peppermint Bark, Almond Toffee or Sun Brittle)

Small: $38/24 pieces, 1/4 lb candy
Med: $57/36 pieces, 1/3 lb candy
Large: $75/48 pieces, 1/2 lb candy

European Specialty Assortment:
Spritz Cookies
Belgian Lukken Cookies
Pepperkaker Tomte Cutouts

Small: $40/24 pieces
Medium: $60/36 pieces
Large: $80/48 pieces
Sugar Cookie Cutouts
$15/dozen plain
$25/dozen decorated

Gingerbread Boys & Girls
$15/dozen plain
$20/dozen decorated

Italian Butter Cookies

Norwegian Krumkake

Belgian Waffle Cookies (Lukken)

Pepperkaker Tomte Cookies

Peppermint Buttermilk Brownies
Candy Sampler
Almond Toffee, Peppermint Bark,
Sun Brittle
$15 /half pound

Peppermint Bark or Sun Brittle
$14/half pound

Almond Toffee
$16/half pound

Triple Nut Spicy Chex Mix
$20/12-ounce tin

Savory Cocktail Assortment
Old Bay Cheddar Cookies
Spicy Chex Mix
Bacon Blue Cheese Scones
Small: $40
Large: $

Happily sprinkling baking joy to the Fargo-Moorhead metro area.

Please reach out by email to with any questions and be sure to let us know how you heard about us so we can say thank you to our friendly customers!

When you place your order, you are supporting Sarah’s home-based business and helping her indulge her passion for baking!

If someone referred you to SarahBakes, please include their name in your order form so we can sprinkle them with more sweetness!

Fargo, North Dakota

Please complete the following fields: