SarahBakes Menu

I will have limited availability for custom orders this summer in order to spend time with my family. I may have some pop-up events if time permits, where you can buy small quantities of my SarahBakes specialties, so be sure to sign up for my mailing list to receive updates on all future events.

For custom order requests, please send me an email to and include the following details:

  • Date of your event
  • Items you wish to order (custom cookies, quiches, cupcakes, scones, etc.)
  • Quantity needed
  • Theme, if applicable

I will reply to you within 24 hours of receiving your email to confirm if I am available on your requested date and further discuss the details of your order Once the details are confirmed, payment is required and I will send you an invoice with a link for online payment.

For Custom Cookie Orders:

Custom cookie orders start at $40 per dozen for basic designs with 1-2 shapes and 1-2 colors (plus white). Prices increase depending on the level of detail and difficulty, number of shapes and colors and if writing is required. Sarah works with both royal icing and buttercream frosting to decorate the cookies, depending on your preference. Individual packaging is available for an additional fee of $6 per dozen.

Sarah prefers at least 2 weeks notice for custom orders and a rush fee of $10 may be applied to orders made within one week of pick-up.

All baked goods are lovingly made by Sarah using only premium ingredients, including pure Madagascar Bourbon vanilla extract, Callebaut Belgian chocolate, Ghirardelli chocolate chips, North Dakota flours, sugars and honey, pure maple syrup, and grade AA unsalted butter.

SarahBakes is happy to serve the local Fargo-Moorhead area and North Dakota market, with delivery available in select areas for a fee of $7.

Because each order is made from scratch by Sarah in her home kitchen, there may be limited availability of popular items. Once your order is received, you will receive a personal email from Sarah within 24 hours to confirm each item and provide details to submit your payment online. Full payment is required in advance to secure your order.

*IMPORTANT: Please be advised that SarahBakes baked goods may contain or come into contact with peanuts, tree nuts, gluten products or other allergens. If you have any food allergies, please let us know that we can confirm if we are able to accommodate your order.

This is a

To place your order, please complete the form below and
Sarah will reply to confirm within 24 hours. Thank you!

We have introduced a new format for our order form and hope it makes your experience more user-friendly. Once you submit your order, you will receive an auto-generated email right away, and Sarah will then confirm your order within 24 hours. If you do not hear from Sarah within that time, please send us an email to and we will assist you from there. Many thanks!